Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - North AmericaEU edition | APAC edition

News > Markets

Read more breaking news


VIDEO dispatches from Expo West 2017

Kite Hill weighs into plant ‘milk’ debate: ‘Do electric cars not get to call themselves cars because they don’t have a combustion engine?’


By Elaine Watson+


Kite Hill weighs into plant ‘milk’ debate at Expo West

An electric vehicle uses a very different propulsion system to the internal combustion engine, but it also has four wheels, and gets you from A to B, which to most consumers, makes it a 'car.' So isn't it time to apply the same logic to plant-based 'milk' 'cheese,' and 'yogurt'? asks the CEO of almond-fueled brand Kite Hill.

Brand owner Lyrical Foods makes almond milk from nuts and water, and then cultures it using proprietary cultures and enzymes to separate it out into solids and liquids, just as traditional cheese makers do.

Its products (almond milk cheeses, cream-cheese-style cheeses, chilled ravioli, and yogurts) are now in several thousand stores including Whole Foods, Sprouts, and The Fresh Market, and rolling out into Target, Kroger and Safeway/Albertsons stores.

Speaking to FoodNavigator-USA at the Expo West show in Anaheim, CEO Matthew Sade said the fact that the FDA is not cracking down on firms using terms such as ‘almondmilk’ (although standards of identity dictate that ‘milk’ refers exclusively to the lacteal secretions of dairy cows) is likely because there is no evidence that consumers are being misled (a view backed up by some federal judges in the case of soy- and almond-milk).

The FDA needs to step in an provide clarity for all stakeholders

As leading plant-based dairy brands (Silk, Almond Breeze) have recently been targeted in a new wave of false advertising lawsuits on this issue, and legislators are urging the FDA to enforce dairy standards of identity via the Dairy Pride Act , however, the FDA now needs to actively intervene such that all stakeholders are crystal clear on its position, he argued.

While some commentators believe that the FDA's apparent lack of interest in enforcing "antiquated" standards of identity should be taken as a sign that it's OK to start using terms such as 'vegan cheese,' or 'almond ice cream,' plaintiff's attorneys and state lawmakers may beg to differ, said Sade, who currently uses terms such as ‘artisan almond milk products’ to describe his dairy-free cheese to avoid legal hot water.

“The mandate for the FDA is to avoid consumer confusion and to do what’s in the best interests in consumers… I would suggest that they [the FDA] just clarify the fact that absolutely no one is being misled [by the use of dairy terms in plant-based products].

We just want to be able to use terms that consumers recognize at a glance

But does he have any sympathy with the dairy lobby, which says it is simply asking for the FDA to enforce the law?

When standards of identity were originally conceived, adulteration was rife, and consumers were being duped by cheap knock-offs purporting to be dairy products, said Sade. But modern plant-based food brands such as Kite Hill are not 'purporting' to be dairy products, he said. They just want to be able to use terms that consumers understand so shoppers know at a glance what their products are.

 “Dairy products serve a purpose in your day,” he said. “What they [dairy companies] are actually suggesting is that if the product did not come from a lactating mammal, then it’s not milk, and what I would say is that is entirely false.

“Do electric cars not get to call themselves cars because they don’t have a combustion engine? They transport you from here to there and use new, better cleaner technology and what we have is a product that does the exact same thing.”

Click HERE  to get the National Milk Producers’ perspective on The Dairy Pride Act.

Vegan cheese, yogurt is much harder to make than almondmilk, soymilk

Asked whether dairy-free cheese was a tougher sell than dairy-free milk, he said: “The reason [that consumers of plant-based milks] have not all historically migrated to other categories – yogurt, cheese, butters – isn’t because there isn’t a desire to have them but because products in these segments are technically much more challenging to make…

“But for the first time a company like Kite Hill is able to make a cultured product… that has the taste and texture that people want, and for that reason what we’re going to see is that these other segments [dairy-free cheese, yogurt etc] will claim their fair share of the category at much much greater speed than we’ve seen to date."

Kite Hill - a San Francisco-based brand on a mission to disrupt the dairy case with its cultured nut milk products – closed an $18m fundraising round led by 301 INC (General Mills’ business development and venturing unit) and CAVU Venture Partners in May 2016.

Founded by vegan chef Tal Ronnen, cheesemaker Monte Casino and Stanford biochemist Dr Pat Brown, brand owner Lyrical Foods makes almond milk from nuts and water, and then cultures it using proprietary cultures and enzymes to separate it out into solids and liquids, just as traditional cheese makers do.

9 comments (Comments are now closed)

The plant lobby needs to be honest with itself and with consumers

Cameron, no one confuses peanut butter with butter because one is a white/yellow fat with delicate dairy flavour used for things like baking cakes and frying eggs, while the other is a brown savoury paste used primarily for spreading on bread or making satay sauce. It's pretty obvious to anyone that they are nutritionally different and furthermore, peanut butter is not marketed as a replacement for real butter. Plant-based "milks" are white liquids used in coffee or for pouring over breakfast cereal. Real dairy milk is a white liquid used in coffee or for pouring over breakfast cereal. Plant-based "milks" are marketed as replacement products for real milk. So your argument that no one will confuse the nutritional quality of the two products is extremely weak at best.
Your comment about the term "almond drink" proves the point. Without calling it "milk" no one will make the mistake that it's nutritionally the same as real milk. By calling it "almond drink" people will be forced to ask themselves, 'is this product really milk?'. Of course people should be free to choose either plant-based products or real milk, but they should not be misled into thinking that they are nutritionally equivalent products.

Report abuse

Posted by Jaye
23 March 2017 | 22h032017-03-23T22:03:15Z

Thanks but no thanks, Dairy Lobby

The dairy lobby's claim that terms like "soy milk" and "almond milk" are confusing is absurd. Why would consumers assume that, just because they have "milk" in their name, these products are nutritionally equivalent to cows' milk? I don't assume peanut butter is nutritionally equivalent to butter.

It would be MORE confusing if the FDA enforced this law than if they changed it. What would we call almond milk? "Almond drink"? That doesn't tell me anything about what I'm buying.

And did anyone notice that, under the current FDA definition, you can't even call GOAT milk "milk"? Doesn't seem like a useful definition to me.

Report abuse

Posted by Cameron
20 March 2017 | 12h592017-03-20T12:59:20Z

People know that plant-based milks are not the same as milk - and that's exactly why they buy them

I've seen no evidence to support the idea that consumers "assume nutritional equivalency" between plant-based milk and dairy milk. In fact, the differences between the nutritional labels are a huge part of what is spurring the growth of these products. Health-conscious consumers are looking for low-calorie, low-fat, cholesterol-free, and hormone-free alternatives that still taste creamy and delicious -- and that's precisely what plant-based milks offer.

Report abuse

Posted by Liz
17 March 2017 | 18h282017-03-17T18:28:28Z

Read all comments (9)

Related products

As soda sales fall, kombucha rises

As soda sales fall, kombucha rises

Tumbling soda sales have opened the door to the mainstream market for a variety...

Bonafide Provisions expands bone broth's appeal with Drinkable Veggies

Bonafide Provisions expands the reach and appeal of bone broth with Drinkable Veggies

As recently as two years ago, bone broth was virtually unheard of by the...

Defining dietary fiber at the 2017 IFT show

VIDEO: Should we define dietary fiber on the basis of what it is or what it does?

Which ingredients should be classified as dietary fibers and why? Elaine Watson caught up...

Sugar Reduction: What’s next? At IFT, companies weigh in

How will added sugar labeling change the market? At IFT, companies weigh in

The controversial requirement to list added sugar on the nutrition facts panel has divided...

Corbion's trans fat-free emulsifiers allow manufacturers to 're-engineer' cakes

Corbion's trans fat-free emulsifiers allow manufacturers to 're-engineer' cakes

"The conversion away from partially hydrogenated oils is really an opportunity to re-engineer cakes...

Cargill R&D VP talks ‘processed’ food, EverSweet, at IFT 2017

VIDEO: Cargill R&D VP talks ‘processed’ food: ‘All food is made of chemicals’

To many consumers, ‘processed food’ is just another term for ‘junk food.’ It’s hard...

Entomo Farms talks edible insects at IFT 2017

Entomo Farms: 'We’re one of the most recognized [edible insect] brands across the world now'

Canadian bug powder supplier Entomo Farms is still doing most of its business with...

Clean meat labeling and regulation in focus at IFT 2017

VIDEO: Will we need a new regulatory framework for clean (cultured) meat?

Producing ‘clean’ meat by culturing cells – instead of raising or slaughtering animals -...

IFT 2017 green banana flour in focus

VIDEO: ‘Green banana flour has the functionality of a starch and the label of a fruit…’

One product that generated quite a buzz at the IFT show this year was...

Retail competition heats up as consumers seek more ethnic products

Competition among retailers heats up as consumers seek more diverse, ethnic products

Consumer demand for products that are authentic and ethnic is not only prompting brand...

Soup-to-Nuts podcast: The return of consumers to home kitchens

Soup-to-Nuts podcast: The opportunities & challenges of consumers' return to home kitchens

Despite continued pressure from the on-the-go lifestyles that dominate today’s culture and have fueled...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Key strategies for innovation from Kraft Heinz

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Key strategies for innovation & renovation from Kraft Heinz

A commonly held perception of the ongoing renaissance in the food and beverage industry...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: What does it take to win a pitch slam?

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: What does it take to win a pitch slam?

For time-strapped entrepreneurs who are brave enough to take the stage, competing in pitch-slams...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Can duck be a dark horse of animal proteins?

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Can duck become the dark horse of animal proteins?

When it comes to eating meat in the US, chicken, without a doubt, is...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: The business case for kosher certification

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: The business case for kosher certification

Ethical claims on food and beverages sold in the US are almost as ubiquitous...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Hemp is overcoming hurdles to become superfood

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: How hemp is overcoming hurdles to become the next superfood star

Nutrition-packed, environmentally sustainable and already notoriously well-known – although partly for the wrong reasons...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Seeds emerge as superfood powerhouse

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Nutrient-dense seeds emerge as superfood powerhouse

Nuts and seeds in the US are finally reaching superfood status, thanks in part...

Soup-To-Nuts podcast: 3 trends driving growth in bottled water

Soup-To-Nuts podcast: Three trends driving growth in the bottled water category

After years of steady growth in the high single-digits, consumption of water in the...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: grain-free vs ancient grain trends

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Gluten free movement spawns divergent grain-free vs ancient grain trends

As the tenacious gluten-free trend continues to grow and mature into a market behemoth...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Agency enforcement and litigation targets

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: FDA & FTC move forward with enforcement even with some regulations in limbo

New regulations and draft guidances may be on hold at many federal agencies until...

Key Industry Events

Promotional Features

Content Provided by Fonterra

Way forward with whey protein