SUBSCRIBE

Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - North AmericaEU edition | Asian edition

News > R&D

Read more breaking news

 

 

Diet drinks and satiety: Kids don’t compensate for missing calories from other sources, says study

3 commentsBy Stephen DANIELLS , 11-Dec-2013
Last updated on 27-May-2014 at 21:07 GMT

Diet drinks and satiety: Kids don’t compensate for missing calories from other sources, says study

Sugar-sweetened and sugar-free beverages produce similar satiety in children, says a new study that challenges the oft-quoted hypothesis that artificially sweetened drinks make people crave sweeter foods or serve as an appetite stimulant.

Data collected over 18 months from 146 children in The Netherlands indicated that there were no statistically significant differences in measures on a five-point satiety scale between children who consumed artificially sweetened sugar-free beverages or a similarly looking and tasting sugar-sweetened beverage.

The results, published in PLoS One , may explain earlier data from the same researchers which found that children in the diet group accumulated less body fat, compared to children in the sugar group.

The study adds ever more weight to the potential of artificial sweeteners to be safe and effective tools for weight management.

Looking to the literature

Some commentators still argue that regular consumption of diet sodas can induce “metabolic derangements”, which put users at “increased risk of excessive weight gain, metabolic syndrome, type-2 diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.”

However, a 2010 review in the British Journal of Nutrition found that “there is no consistent evidence that low-energy sweeteners increase appetite or subsequent food intake, cause insulin release or affect blood pressure in normal subjects”. A more recent study - click here  -  published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition in Feb 2013 came to the same conclusion.

In addition, a 2012 study also published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (click here ) showed that replacing caloric beverages with non-caloric beverages was an effective weight-loss strategy, while a 2009 published in the International Journal of Obesity (click here ) showed that those who have lost weight and successfully kept it off adopt a number of strategies, including drinking more artificially sweetened beverages.

The new study supports this position, with scientists from VU University in Amsterdam and Deakin University in Australia writing: “When we substituted sugar-free beverages for the sugar-containing drinks that children drank habitually, they apparently did not feel a need to eat more of other foods and drinks to compensate for the missing calories.”

Study details

Led by Janne de Ruyter, the researchers randomized 203 children aged between 7 and 11 to one of two groups: The first group received 250 mL per day of an artificially sweetened sugar-free drink, while the second group got a similarly looking and tasting sugar-sweetened drink.

“We tested satiety under real-life conditions, i.e. during the morning break at school when children consumed their beverage together with their usual snack,” they explained. “We assume that satiety was determined by snack intake – mostly crackers, sweets, or fruits - , beverage volume, and caloric content of the drink. Mean caloric intake from snacks and volume of drinks were the same between groups but the sugar-free drinks contained 26 g less sucrose. We conclude that the sugar content of the drinks did not have a measurable effect on satiety.

“This finding is consistent with short term experiments in adults that also found similar levels of satiety following sugar-containing and sugar-free beverages.”

Formulation lessons

There could also be formulation lessons for beverage companies, suggested the researchers, with the observation that the children liked and wanted the sugar-sweetened drinks slightly more than the sugar-free versions.

“The pleasantness of artificially sweetened products may be highly dependent on the type and mix of sweeteners used and on other aspects of product formulation,” they said.

Despite this, liking and wanting did decline over time for both types of drinks – after all, the researchers were asking the children to consume the same beverage every day for 18 months.

Source: PLoS One
8(10): e78039, doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0078039
“The Effect of Sugar-Free Versus Sugar-Sweetened Beverages on Satiety, Liking and Wanting: An 18 Month Randomized Double-Blind Trial in Children”
Authors: J.C. de Ruyter, M.B. Katan, L.D.J. Kuijper, D.G. Liem, M.R. Olthof

3 comments (Comments are now closed)

Children didn't feel a need to consume food again

I'm a nursing student, I ever study about the nutrition, I just knew that there is no different with the children who consumes sugar free beverages than sugar sweetener baverages.

Because i think that must be have different about sugar and nutrition, But the fact, when children use sugar sweetener baverages, they don't feel a need to take some food or drinks again.

Thank you for sharing this great information

Report abuse

Posted by Darah Tinggi
02 March 2014 | 00h43

Jury's still out; err on the side of precaution

I'm a registered dietitian and like many of my colleagues, I do NOT recommend artificial sweeteners. I prefer to ask: what are the alternatives? Perhaps lightly sweetened beverages, and developing a palate for less sweet foods. This recent opinion piece provides further food for thought on the topic.
http://download.cell.com/images/edimages/Trends/EndoMetabolism/tem_888.pdf

Report abuse

Posted by Melinda Hemmelgarn, M.S., R.D.
17 December 2013 | 19h18

Comment

The primary study cited here adds to the significant body of research, which proves sugar-sweetened beverages containing low- and no-calorie sweeteners are, in fact, an effective diet tool. It also contradicts claims that these beverages cause people to consume more calories from other sources.

As we’ve said, much scientific analysis backs these conclusions up, including a randomized clinical trial published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition briefly mentioned in this piece. This study concluded that those who consumed diet beverages in place of caloric ones consumed fewer calories than other control groups, including those who consumed only water. It also determined that the consumption of diet beverages does not enhance preference for sweet foods and beverages: http://bit.ly/Ik4zjC.

Leading health organizations, such as the American Diabetes Association and the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, have been saying for years that low-calorie sweeteners are an effective tool for weight loss and management. This study further supports this fact. www.letsclearitup.org

Report abuse

Posted by Maureen Beach
13 December 2013 | 17h15

Related products

Key Industry Events

 

Access all events listing

Our events, Events from partners...