SUBSCRIBE

Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - North AmericaEU edition | Asian edition

News > Suppliers

Gluten-free trend could fall like ‘a house of cards’

34 commentsBy Caroline Scott-Thomas , 23-Mar-2010
Last updated on 06-Apr-2010 at 13:09 GMT

The mainstream adoption of gluten-free diets is a movement on the way out, according to trends forecaster Suzy Badaracco, president of Culinary Tides.

Gluten-free foods have rapidly increased in popularity over the past few years – partly as a result of better diagnosis of celiac disease, an autoimmune disorder triggered by exposure to gluten, the protein in wheat, barley, rye and spelt. However, there has also been a mass movement toward gluten-free products by those who have self-diagnosed wheat or gluten intolerance or who believe gluten-free to be a healthier way of eating. And the gluten-free market has boomed, with an average annual growth rate of 28 percent since 2004, according to market research organization Packaged Facts.

However, Badaracco told FoodNavigator-USA.com that people who have tried adhering to a gluten-free diet for reasons other than celiac disease are drifting back to gluten-containing foods, and that this drift is likely to pick up pace.

“This is a house of cards just waiting to fall,” she said. “It’s a medical diet, right? It’s hard to stick to.”

As well as her trend forecasting business for the food industry, Badaracco is also a qualified dietitian, and she said that those who choose to avoid gluten-containing foods often end up with poorly balanced diets.

“They’re missing fiber, missing B vitamins,” she said. “And these foods are higher in fat typically that other products.”

Lasting legacy for celiacs

However, even if people without celiac disease decide to go back to eating gluten, wider availability of better, tastier gluten-free products could be one of the longer lasting consequences of the gluten-free movement, as food manufacturers have worked hard to formulate better quality products to tap into the trend, with flavor and sensory qualities that appeal to consumers.

Part of that has been about boosting the nutritional profile of gluten-free foods, which traditionally have been based on relatively nutrient-poor ingredients, such as potato and corn starches, with xanthan or guar gum to improve texture. As gluten-free entered the mainstream, companies increased their experimentation with a range of more nutrient-rich grains and flours, such as quinoa, amaranth, pea flour and buckwheat.

Where to from here?

Badaracco, who works directly with food manufacturers to provide them with relevant information on food trends, said that companies are reacting in different ways to the information she is giving them about what she sees as a less-than-rosy future for gluten-free demand.

She said: “I have two clients taking different pathways with the exact same information. One is downsizing – because we still need good products – but another is going in, making money, and then getting out.”

The federal government has estimated that there are about 3m people in the United States who suffer from celiac disease, or about one in every 133 Americans, although only 40,000 to 60,000 have been diagnosed.

34 comments (Comments are now closed)

Proper Testing Important

I would agree w/ the writer that individuals that are self dx. will slip back. However in my experience the blood test is inacurate and gives many false negatives. The biopsy is the only true way to find out. Given its better reliability, once its done and is found to be positive. Then the patient will be very willing to stay on a reduction diet due to their health benifits.

Report abuse

Posted by Dr. Brad
28 May 2010 | 15h29

Readers missing the point

I think it's the readers here who have missed the point rather than the writer.
She is not denigrating coeliac disease at all. She is talking about those people who self-diagnose as being gluten intolerant and will probably drift back to eating gluten because it is a difficult diet to stick to - if you don't have coeliac disease!
I think those of you who got hot under the collar over this should read it again.
She is sticking up for coeliacs - and hopes that even though the fad may soon die, that still there will be better foods for those who have no choice but to avoid gluten.

Report abuse

Posted by Penina
28 May 2010 | 11h36

Response to Vic Cherikoff

Perhaps people in Australia are willing to ignore the fact that Celiac is a proven medical condition that destroys the villi in the small intestine, thereby causing malabsorption and susceptibility to other autoimmune diseases. But I will not abandon my GF diet in favor of a "Juice" until the medical community can prove beyond a doubt that it is a cure. At this point, there is no cure beyond adhering to a gluten-free diet. I hope no one else chooses to believe this nonsense.

Report abuse

Posted by Mary Viox
15 April 2010 | 16h54

Read all comments (34)

Related products