SUBSCRIBE

Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - North AmericaEU edition | Asian edition

Report abuse about a comment

Poor design

There are several inadequacies in the experimental design:-
1) the rats receiving sweeteners derived only 12.6% of their energy from artificially-sweetened yogurt, the rest from a fully-balanced lab chow. The rats receiving sugar derived 24% of their energy from yogurt containing 20% sugar. The "sugar" rats thus received a nutritionally inferior diet compared to the others.
2) There was no "all chow/no sugar" control group.
3) Only 10 rats per group.
4) Unrealistic levels of sweetener used: aspartame was 650% more than would be used in practice, saccharin was 2600% higher than would be allowed in the EU.

This is indeed a difficult area experimentally, and the conclusion is more complex than your story suggests.

Posted by John Fry
29 November 2012 | 15h40

Please fill in the box below to tell us why you feel the post breaks our rules. When you are finished, click on "Send" so that it can be reviewed by a moderator.

Your name *
Your email *

We will not publish your email on the site

Reason *

Back to: Sweeteners linked to higher weight gain: Rat study

Spotlight

Perfect Bar sales grow 120% in 2014 says CEO Bill Keith

Bars get fresh! Perfect Bar founder on bootstrapping, refusing to quit, and creating a completely new snacking category

While it’s taken a while to convince retail buyers that stocking protein bars next to kombucha in...

GMO Arctic apples and Simplot low-acrylamide potatoes safe, says FDA

GMO update: Non-browning Arctic apples and Innate low-acrylamide potatoes are safe, says FDA

The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) says two high-profile genetically engineered foods - Simplot's low acrylamide...

Judge tosses ‘no refined sugars’ case vs KIND Healthy Snacks

Judge tosses ‘no refined sugars’ case vs KIND Healthy Snacks, but attorney says it had a lucky escape

A judge in Illinois has thrown out a class action lawsuit against KIND LLC over “no refined...

Grocers rearrange stores to better position healthy foods, FMI survey

Grocers rearrange stores to better position healthy foods, FMI survey finds

As consumers’ understanding of food as a health management tool expands, retailers nationwide are changing how they...

NPA lobbies to protect definition of organic to include non-GMO

NPA lobbies legislators to protect definition of organic to include non-GMO

Consumer confusion about organic verses non-GMO claims abounds, and the Natural Product Association wants to set the...

Dave's Killer Bread takes on the carb-bashers at Expo West

Bread is back! Dave's Killer Bread takes on the carb-bashers at Expo West

While retail sales of packaged bread have been pretty sluggish in recent years, one company that’s bucking...

One out of 13 children has food allergies, Enjoy Life Foods

Enjoy Life Foods at Expo West: One out of 13 children in North America has food allergies

One out of 13 children in North America has food allergies today compared with one in 50...

Tiny Farms: Edible insects will be be mainstream in future

Tiny Farms: Edible insects are a novelty today, but they’ll be mainstream tomorrow

Two or three years ago, you could count the number of US firms using cricket flour in...

Kraft & Heinz merge to accelerate growth, expand distribution globally

Kraft & Heinz merge to accelerate growth and expand distribution globally

The mega-merger between Kraft Food Group and H.J. Heinz Company announced March 25 will allow the U.S....

Sales of indulgent snacks outpace healthy options, IRI data shows

Sales of indulgent snacks outpace healthy options, IRI data shows

Consumers may be seeking more healthy and fresh foods in general, but when it comes to snacks,...