Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - North AmericaEU edition | APAC edition

News > Manufacturers

Read more breaking news



Could the biotech disclosure law help shift perception of GMOs from good vs evil to simply a choice?

1 comment

By Elizabeth Crawford


How to shift perception of GMOs from good vs evil to simply a choice

In many ways, the conversation about GMOs has been a debate about good versus evil, but ingredient supplier Cargill wants to shift the discussion to one simply about choice – a goal that one executive says can only be achieved if manufacturers and suppliers start talking to consumers about the benefits GMOs offer. 

“There is a disconnect between science and consumer understanding” of genetically modified organisms, which manufacturers and suppliers must help repair, Mike Robach, vice president of corporate food safety, quality and regulatory affairs at Cargill, told FoodNavigator-USA.

He explained at the Grocery Manufacturers Association’s Science Forum in Washington, DC, last month, “We have a very interesting dilemma, which is we are using science and technology to increase food production, increase the efficiency of food production, lower costs, actually aid sustainability and the fact that we are now creating crops with fewer inputs thanks to technology and genetic engineering,” but “the problem is it has never really been articulated in a way to consumers.”

As a result, GMOs are a “black box” that many consumers don’t understand, which can be frightening, he said.

“The benefits have never really been talked about to the consumer at the consumer level,” he said. For example, “What does it mean as a consumer? Why is this good? … We have to do a better job from the farm all the way to the consumer being able to tell the message and break down some of the silos that exist.”

Robach cautioned, however, that as companies begin talking about the benefits of GMOs, they also must refrain from disparaging non-GMO options. Instead, he said, they should let the facts and values of both options speak for themselves.

“We need to have all the stakeholders together to talk not about good or bad, but talk about the attributes of conventionally raised versus non-GMO so we are not really polarizing the situation,” he said, adding, “Part of the problem today is that the non-GMO folks are trying to demonize conventional ag, and the conventional ag folks are back on their heels saying, ‘We are not doing anything wrong. We are actually applying science and we are increasing yields. We are increasing efficiencies. We are lowering costs. We are going to be doing things that make more nutritionally complete products.’ So, we have to figure out a way collectively that we can put this in a position of choice as opposed to good and evil.”

Cargill is taking its own advice by offering its customers a choice between genetically modified ingredients and non-GMO ingredients.

Robach explained that Cargill is “very technology forward” and believes in innovation and science that is properly vetted for safety and suitability, but also believes in choice and providing solutions to its customers. This is why, he said, Cargill also created a number of non-GMO supply chains to help manufacturers meet consumer demand for these options.

“For us, it is not about right or wrong or good or bad. These are just choices that people make in terms of what they want to eat. Conventionally raised is great, wonderful, it is wholesome, nutritious and safe. And the same can be said for non-GMO,” he said.

Could the disclosure law level the playing field?

In some ways, the National Bioengineered Food Disclosure Law, could facilitate a shift in the conversation by mandating that companies tell consumers when they use genetically engineered ingredients and creating an opportunity to explain their choice and the benefits of the ingredients.

And one way to do that without cluttering packaging is with SmartLabel, according to Jim Flannery, senior executive vice president of operations and industry collaboration at the Grocery Manufacturers Association.

“The GMO disclosure law says a brand must disclose whether they contain genetically engineered ingredients and they have given three options: They can use text, they can use a symbol or they can use digital disclosure,” he said.

Using SmartLabel to digitally disclose the presence of GMOs also provides companies space to explain to consumers what GMOs are, when they are in a product and why and what they do that is different than non-GMO ingredients, he said.

Robach agrees that disclosure through SmartLabel is a major step forward in increasing transparency and changing the conversation about GMOs.

“We in the industry need to do a better job of talking about science and benefits. So this gets back to transparency, so you can start rebuilding the trust that really eroded away because there was not transparency” initially, he said. “We have to figure a way to take that space back and talk about it more and more openly and more clearly in language that consumers can understand.”

1 comment (Comments are now closed)

It is also about the consumer

The major thrust of GMO has been consumer benefit. It has all been about Farmer, Seed Companies and Producers benefit. What is in it for the consumer? They get all the pain and none of the gain.

Talking higher yields, less pesticides does not resonate with lots of consumers. Lower prices, health benefits does.

Report abuse

Posted by Phil Roberts
06 May 2017 | 21h532017-05-06T21:53:55Z

As soda sales fall, kombucha rises

As soda sales fall, kombucha rises

Tumbling soda sales have opened the door to the mainstream market for a variety...

Bonafide Provisions expands bone broth's appeal with Drinkable Veggies

Bonafide Provisions expands the reach and appeal of bone broth with Drinkable Veggies

As recently as two years ago, bone broth was virtually unheard of by the...

Defining dietary fiber at the 2017 IFT show

VIDEO: Should we define dietary fiber on the basis of what it is or what it does?

Which ingredients should be classified as dietary fibers and why? Elaine Watson caught up...

Sugar Reduction: What’s next? At IFT, companies weigh in

How will added sugar labeling change the market? At IFT, companies weigh in

The controversial requirement to list added sugar on the nutrition facts panel has divided...

Corbion's trans fat-free emulsifiers allow manufacturers to 're-engineer' cakes

Corbion's trans fat-free emulsifiers allow manufacturers to 're-engineer' cakes

"The conversion away from partially hydrogenated oils is really an opportunity to re-engineer cakes...

Cargill R&D VP talks ‘processed’ food, EverSweet, at IFT 2017

VIDEO: Cargill R&D VP talks ‘processed’ food: ‘All food is made of chemicals’

To many consumers, ‘processed food’ is just another term for ‘junk food.’ It’s hard...

Entomo Farms talks edible insects at IFT 2017

Entomo Farms: 'We’re one of the most recognized [edible insect] brands across the world now'

Canadian bug powder supplier Entomo Farms is still doing most of its business with...

Clean meat labeling and regulation in focus at IFT 2017

VIDEO: Will we need a new regulatory framework for clean (cultured) meat?

Producing ‘clean’ meat by culturing cells – instead of raising or slaughtering animals -...

IFT 2017 green banana flour in focus

VIDEO: ‘Green banana flour has the functionality of a starch and the label of a fruit…’

One product that generated quite a buzz at the IFT show this year was...

Retail competition heats up as consumers seek more ethnic products

Competition among retailers heats up as consumers seek more diverse, ethnic products

Consumer demand for products that are authentic and ethnic is not only prompting brand...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: How to refine a pitch

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: How to refine a pitch to woo investors and score retail distribution

Whether it is trying to raise money, build brand awareness or convince a buyer...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: The rise of high pressure processing

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: The rise and potential of high pressure processing for fresh, clean products

In general, talking about how a food or beverage is processed is not a...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Ads that show cooking with kids are relatable

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Tweaking ads to show cooking with kids makes brands relatable

Images of mom preparing dinner alone in the kitchen for her busy family have...

Soup-to-Nuts podcast: The return of consumers to home kitchens

Soup-to-Nuts podcast: The opportunities & challenges of consumers' return to home kitchens

Despite continued pressure from the on-the-go lifestyles that dominate today’s culture and have fueled...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Key strategies for innovation from Kraft Heinz

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Key strategies for innovation & renovation from Kraft Heinz

A commonly held perception of the ongoing renaissance in the food and beverage industry...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: What does it take to win a pitch slam?

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: What does it take to win a pitch slam?

For time-strapped entrepreneurs who are brave enough to take the stage, competing in pitch-slams...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Can duck be a dark horse of animal proteins?

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Can duck become the dark horse of animal proteins?

When it comes to eating meat in the US, chicken, without a doubt, is...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: The business case for kosher certification

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: The business case for kosher certification

Ethical claims on food and beverages sold in the US are almost as ubiquitous...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Hemp is overcoming hurdles to become superfood

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: How hemp is overcoming hurdles to become the next superfood star

Nutrition-packed, environmentally sustainable and already notoriously well-known – although partly for the wrong reasons...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Seeds emerge as superfood powerhouse

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Nutrient-dense seeds emerge as superfood powerhouse

Nuts and seeds in the US are finally reaching superfood status, thanks in part...

Key Industry Events