Special edition: Applying health claims

When FTC gets tough on misleading marketing

By Lorraine Heller

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags: Weight loss, Federal trade commission, Nutrition, Ftc

NutraIngredients-USA examines the enforcement strategy of the US
Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in its efforts to ensure that the
marketing claims made by food and dietary supplement manufacturers
are accurate and substantiated.

The fourth in a series of articles on health claims sets out FTC's process and remedies, and also provides examples of recent actions taken by the agency. In broad terms, the nation's Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates the use of health claims on product labels, while FTC handles claims made in product advertising. However, some overlap may occur when products are being investigated. Process and Remedies ​Michelle Rusk, from FTC's division of advertising practices, highlighted the following in relation to the agency's enforcement avenues and consequences:

  • Administrative or Federal Court - with most of FTC's cases now going into Federal Court

  • Broad liability - with anybody actively involved in the creation of advertising being liable

  • Injunctions and asset freezes

  • Disgorgement/redress

  • Suspended judgments

  • Criminal liason unit - "Sometimes, civil law enforcement isn't adequate"

She told attendees at Expo West in Anaheim, California, last month, that FTC enforcement priorities are:

  • Health and safety

  • Promises to treat/cure serious diseases

  • Children - "Anything that makes dodgy claims about being good for kids"

  • Outright false claims

  • Widespread or severe consumer injury

Recent actions ​In the specialty food and dietary supplement category, weight loss has proved to b a major focus for FTC. "We're never short of targets in the weight loss industry,"​ Rusk stated. Example 1: ​ She highlighted the example of Centro Natural Services, which marketed a weight loss soap and pills. The Spanish language informercial claimed that people using these products could lose 35lbs in two months without dieting, and they would never gain the weight back. The case resulted in a $2.3m suspended judgment, with a 2008 stipulated final order. Example 2: ​ Another case involved Chinery and RTC Research & Development LLC, and the Xenadrine EFX weight loss supplement. This contained green tea extract, caffeine and bitter orange. Marketing for the supplement said that it was "clinically proven to deliver dramatic results". ​ However, an examination revealed that the placebo group lost more weight than the test group. In addition, the weight loss was found to result from rigorous exercise and diet. The company also did not disclose that endorsers of the product had been paid up to $20,000. To date, $8m has been collected for consumer redress. Example 3: ​ Another example involved 7 Day Marketing, Inc, which marketed a 7 Day Miracle Cleanse. This product was referred to FTC by industry (ERSP) - a "good example of industry self-regulation". ​ The informercial made claims for AIDS, Alzheimer's, diabetes, arthritis and weight loss. A 'health man' was also allegedly cured of breast cancer and skin cancer without the need for surgery, chemo or radiation. The case resulted in a $14.5m suspended judgment and a broad ban on all infomercials and all advertising of health benefits. Criminal Liaison Unit ​ FTC, a civil law enforcement agency, also works with criminal authorities to stop most serious consumer fraud. Over the past year, there have been federal and state criminal charges against 81 FTC defendants and their associates; 39 convictions/guilty pleas; and 130 years total prison time. Other articles in the series: Choosing Health Claims FDA enforcement action on health claims FTC's two-pronged approach to ensuring accurate marketingLegal advice to avoid FDA/FTC claim clamp-down

Related topics: Dairy-based ingredients

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

How to Make Plant-Based Better for You

How to Make Plant-Based Better for You

SweeGen | 24-Jan-2023 | Technical / White Paper

Plant-based food and beverage sales are booming, thanks to a growing desire among consumers for healthier food options, with sugar among the top ingredients...

Growing Up Bioactives

Growing Up Bioactives

Glanbia Nutritionals | 13-Sep-2022 | Business Advice

Parents are prioritizing their children’s health and wellness with 66% indicating they give their child nutritional supplements once a day*. Support their...

Opportunity Alert: Mobility Matters to your Consumers

Opportunity Alert: Mobility Matters to your Consumers

NZMP (Ingredients by Fonterra) | 16-Aug-2022 | Infographic

The World Health Organization says mobility is critical for healthy ageing, as it’s a core concern seniors face. With mobility’s significant impact on...

Consumers are ditching diets for intuitive eating.

Consumers are ditching diets for intuitive eating.

Fonterra | 02-Aug-2022 | Technical / White Paper

Interest in intuitive eating is reportedly gaining as much traction with consumers as the ketogenic diet. However, without similarly strict macronutrient...

Follow us


View more