Chobani (finally) prevails in evaporated cane juice lawsuit, but other firms still being targeted

By Elaine WATSON

- Last updated on GMT

Chobani (finally) prevails in evaporated cane juice lawsuit, but other firms still being targeted

Related tags: Cane juice, Plaintiff

A high-profile class action lawsuit accusing Chobani of deceiving consumers with the term ‘evaporated cane juice’ on labels has finally been dismissed with prejudice (ie. the plaintiff can’t re-file and the case is officially closed).

In her February 20 order on a suit first filed in May 2012 (Kane et al v Chobani Inc, No. 5:12-cv-02425), which has been amended three times, California federal judge Lucy Koh said it would be “futile​” to allow the plaintiffs to keep pursuing this case.

Among other things, she said, the plaintiffs failed to explain how they “could have realized that dried cane syrup was a form of sugar, but nevertheless believed that evaporated cane juice was not” ​and have not been able to prove that they relied upon the allegedly fraudulent misrepresentations when they bought the yogurts.

More evaporated cane juice cases are being filed weekly

Chobani - which has repeatedly argued that reasonable consumers would know that "the word 'cane' in the ingredient list indicates a sweetener ingredient" -​ said it felt vindicated after months of legal wrangling, telling FoodNavigator-USA: 

"We have always been committed to using only natural ingredients and to marketing our products transparently. We are pleased with the Court’s dismissal of this lawsuit.”

However, many other ECJ-related cases are still moving through the courts - including actions against Amazon Preservation Partners, Inc (Zola acai and pomegranate drinks), Healthy Beverage LLC (Steaz Iced Teas), Santa Cruz Natural, Inc (Lemonade Soda, Orange Mango Soda), Late July Snacks (crackers/snack chips), Blue Diamond, Trader Joe’s and Wallaby Yogurt Co - and more are being filed weekly.

Others, meanwhile, have been settled (last year WhiteWave Foods agreed to replace the term ECJ with ‘organic cane sugar’ or ‘cane sugar’ on its products as part of a settlement).

Plaintiff: 'Evaporated cane juice is not juice at all—it is nothing more than sugar, cleverly disguised'

The latest two lawsuits target Reed’s Inc* (kombucha beverages and other products) and Living Harvest Foods** (Hemp milk products), with the latter asserting that “evaporated cane juice is not juice at all—it is nothing more than sugar, cleverly disguised”.

The plaintiff adds that evaporated cane juice is merely “a ‘healthy’ sounding name made up by the sugar industry years ago to sell sugar to ‘healthy’ food manufacturers for use in their consumer products.”

What does the FDA say?

Last year, WhiteWave Foods agreed to settle a proposed class action over its use of evaporated cane juice on product labels (Singer v. WWF Operating Co. No. 13-CV-21232) and agreed to replace the term with ‘organic cane sugar’ or ‘cane sugar’

Plaintiffs in these lawsuits - many of which have been filed by law firm Pratt & Associates- say the FDA has sent out multiple warning letters and produced draft guidance (click here​) specifically telling firms not​ to use the term ‘evaporated cane juice’ because it is false and misleading and is not a ‘juice’.

They also note that federal regulations instruct that ingredients must be described by their common or usual names, and that to call something ‘juice’ it should be “the aqueous liquid expressed or extracted from one or more fruits or vegetables​”.

 *Shaouli v. Reed’s Inc (No. BC534738 Cal. Super., Los Angeles County).

**Miller v. Living Harvest Foods Inc (No. 2014-2735-CA-01 11th Jud. Cir. Court of State of Florida).

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

5 top trends fueling product preferences

5 top trends fueling product preferences

Cargill | 01-Oct-2020 | Product Presentation

Though many industry events have been postponed, Cargill has created an innovative new way to connect and spark product innovation.

Top Trends Affecting the Growing Snack Category

Top Trends Affecting the Growing Snack Category

AIDP, Inc | 29-Jun-2020 | Infographic

Snacks are growing at double digit rates primarily driven by new forces. Consumers tastes and demographic shifts are propelling snack growth. Consumers...

Convenience foods + culinary standards

Convenience foods + culinary standards

Cargill | 09-Jun-2020 | Technical / White Paper

Keeping pace with modern lifestyles and current trends, today’s convenience category has the opportunity to re-invent itself and earn a consistent place...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more