GUEST ARTICLE: Don’t let the Dirty Dozen scare you... pesticide residues in perspective

By Jeremy Brown, US Farmers & Ranchers Alliance

- Last updated on GMT

Jeremy Brown grows cotton, organic cotton, wheat, rye, grain sorghum, peanuts and sesame in West Texas
Jeremy Brown grows cotton, organic cotton, wheat, rye, grain sorghum, peanuts and sesame in West Texas
If you say the words ‘Dirty Dozen’ to farmers, don’t be surprised if you see them shudder, as this popular - but fallacious - concept isn’t based on science or reality.

The Environmental Working Group (EWG) recently released a ‘Dirty Dozen​’ list of foods – which includes a list of produce with pesticide residues – to encourage the public to buy organic produce.

Purchasing choices are up to the individual, but they don’t need to be directed by fear.

The USDA’s public data​ makes it clear that our food supply, both organic and conventional, is safe, in part due to farmers’ dedication to responsible pesticide use.

The government also regulates pesticide use to reduce residues. Some produce has trace amounts, which can easily be eliminated by running it under water. To put it into perspective, a child could eat 340 apples in one day without any negative effect from pesticides, even if the apples have the highest residue recorded for apples by the USDA (check the Pesticide Calculator here​).

If consumers have lingering doubts, take the Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA's) advice: just wash your produce.  Washing food with water reduces or eliminates residue.

'In some cases, we can plant GMO, pest-resistant, crops around organic crops' 

So, how can people decipher information from both sides when they’re buying food?

Pesticides are used to control weeds, insect infestations, and diseases.

People often believe that organic farmers don’t use pesticides, but they use non-synthetic pesticides​ to protect their crops.

Organic and conventional pest management systems have their own challenges and benefits. 

In some cases, we can plant GMO, pest-resistant, crops around organic crops. This method is effective because the GMO plants act as a pest-resistant barrier around our organic crops.  Because of this method, we have decreased our use of organic pesticides.

Pest problems in organic fields take a precise touch.  Three years ago, we had a sugarcane aphid pest (small sap-sucking insect) in our sorghum field, and we had to use a pesticide, because if we didn’t, we would have lost our entire crop within 48 hours. That’s how fast the aphids will destroy that crop.  We could have used some more natural forms of pesticides, but they have not been as successful at keeping the aphids under control.

With new technologies available on modern farms, pesticide management is more specialized than ever.  Farmers use soil samples, crop consultants, and pesticide applicators to make sure that the exact amount is going into the right place at the precise time.

Neither conventional nor organic food is ‘dirty’ 

Because I farm both organic and non-organic crops, I see both practices from a soil health perspective.  I really focus a lot of my farming on keeping the soil flourishing, because it’s going to be here after I’m long gone. 

At the end of the day, whether you’re planting organic crops or conventional, we’re all farmers.

I’m very sensitive to the practices that I’m using to preserve the land and the environment in both organic and non-organic farming. And thanks to diligent American farming practices, neither conventional nor organic food is ‘dirty’. 

In reality, these foods are healthy, nutritious, and grown by passionate farmers who care what they’re feeding their families and customers.

JeremyBrown-mugshot

Jeremy Brown​ farms 3,000 acres in Texas. He farms both organically and conventionally, growing cotton, wheat, rye, grain sorghum, peanuts, and sesame. All opinions expressed are his own. Funding was from one or more checkoff programs.

Related products

show more

GLOBAL PREFERENCES: TEXTURANTS PLAY A KEY ROLE.

GLOBAL PREFERENCES: TEXTURANTS PLAY A KEY ROLE.

Tate and Lyle | 16-May-2018 | Technical / White Paper

Texture is a matter of taste, and that’s true on a global scale as well. What appeals to consumers in Italy might turn off those in Indonesia. As formulators,...

AmpliVida XOS Prebiotic: Pure, Selective & Effective

AmpliVida XOS Prebiotic: Pure, Selective & Effective

DSM Nutritional Products | 20-Mar-2018 | Technical / White Paper

Join us on Friday, March 9th for a scientific talk on Balancing the Microbiome Through Prebiotics. Learn more about NEW AmpliVida XOS Prebiotic, an organic,...

Related suppliers

2 comments

Non Sequitur

Posted by H. S.,

What are you trying to say with "At the end of the day, whether you're planting organic crops or conventional, we're all farmers."?

Surely this deserves further scrutiny otherwise I could equally say: At the end of the day, whether his name is Harvey Weinstein or Mahatma Gandhi, they are both men.

Report abuse

Not Satisfying

Posted by Kyle,

In reading your article, I'm struck by how unsatisfying it must seem to people who have concerns about synthetic pesticides and genetic modification. For the sake of this comment, I'm not taking sides.

But imagine being incredibly suspicious of FDA's track record, and then reading, "trust your Food and Drug Administration's advice".
"Trust us; we're experts" isn't a great rallying cry to those who don't trust you.

Neither is "Hey, we have GMOs that also do a great job!" if you're suspicious of GMOs.

This didn't seem like an answer to those who have concerns, but rather a way of preaching to the choir who already shares your views.

Just a thought.

Report abuse

Follow us

Featured Events

View more

Products

View more

Webinars