Texture plays a key role in product acceptance, study reveals

By Mary Ellen Shoup contact

- Last updated on GMT

 ©GettyImages / skynesher
©GettyImages / skynesher

Related tags: Chocolate, Texture

Along with taste and smell, texture plays an equally important role in our like or dislike of specific food, according to researchers at Penn State University.

According to a study​ conducted in the Penn State Sensory Evaluation Center in the College of Agricultural Sciences, researchers found that people are able to detect even minor differences in texture because of the human mouth's sensitivity to different levels of pressure based on varying particle sizes of a food.

Despite being a key driver of the acceptance or rejection of foods, co-author of the study and associate professor of food science at Penn State John Hayes pointed out, oral texture perception is not at as well understood and studied compared to taste and smell, two other sensory inputs critical for flavor perception.

"We've known for a long time that individual differences in taste and smell can cause differences in liking and food intake -- now it looks like the same might be true for texture,"​ said Hayes. "This may have implications for parents of picky eaters since texture is often a major reason food is rejected."

The perception of food texture arises from the interaction of a food with mechanoreceptors (tiny sensory receptors that respond to physical stimuli) in the mouth, Hayes noted. Texture perception depends on neural impulses carried by multiple nerves. 

Hayes noted that the reason texture perception may not be as well understood as taste and smell, is that texture typically is not noticed when it is within an acceptable range, but that it is a major factor in rejection if an adverse texture is present, said Hayes.

Analyzing texture in chocolate

To conduct the research, Hayes and his team selected to study the texture perception of two different samples of dark chocolate. Hayes explained that because chocolate is a semi-solid suspension of fine particles from cocoa and sugar dispersed in a continuous fat base  it is an ideal food for the study of texture.

For chocolate specifically, oral texture is a critical quality attribute, with grittiness often being used to differentiate bulk chocolate from premium chocolates, noted Hayes. 

"Chocolate manufacturers spend lots of energy grinding cocoa and sugar down to the right particle size for optimal acceptability by consumers,"​ Hayes said. "This work may help them figure out when it is good enough without going overboard."

Participants were split into groups based on high or low tongue sensitivity and then were asked their perceptions about various textures in two types of commercially available dark chocolate (ultra premium Scharffen Berger Bittersweet Dark chocolate and less premium ChocoLove Strong Dark chocoloate).

The research included 111 volunteer tasters who had their tongues checked for physical sensitivity using a toothbrush-like device that gauged their ability to discern between different amount of pressure applied to their tongues.  Participants were split into groups based on high or low tongue sensitivity and then were asked their perceptions about various textures in two types of commercially available dark chocolate (ultra premium Scharffen Berger Bittersweet Dark chocolate and less premium ChocoLove Strong Dark chocolate).

Researchers found a significant correlation between chocolate-texture discrimination and pressure-point sensitivity for the high-acuity group on the center tongue. A similar relationship was not seen for data from the lateral edge of the tongue. Researchers found that 17 of 20 of more acute individuals correctly identified the grittier chocolate versus 12 of 24 less acute individuals. 

"These findings are novel, as we are unaware of previous work showing a relationship between oral pressure sensitivity and ability to detect differences in particle size in a food product,"​ Hayes said.

"Collectively, these findings suggest that texture-detection mechanisms, which underpin point-pressure sensitivity, likely contribute to the detection of particle size in food such as chocolate."

Takeaway for chocolate manufacturers

For chocolate specifically, oral texture is a critical quality attribute, with grittiness often being used to differentiate bulk chocolate from premium chocolates, noted Hayes. 

The results of the study show a link between an individual's sensitivity to pressure (a proxy for particle size) and his or sensitivity to the grittiness of chocolate. 

"Chocolate manufacturers spend lots of energy grinding cocoa and sugar down to the right particle size for optimal acceptability by consumers,"​ Hayes said. "This work may help them figure out when it is good enough without going overboard."

Related news

Related products

Enhancing Bakery’s Appeal

Enhancing Bakery’s Appeal

Bunge Oils | 23-Sep-2019 | Technical / White Paper

Many of the attributes consumers love about bakery are determined by the type of fat bakers use. Some initial PHO substitutes did not fully meet sensory...

H&F – special pectins for innovative confectionery

H&F – special pectins for innovative confectionery

H&F – Innovative Solutions for your Product Developments | 19-Mar-2018 | Data Sheet

H&F special pectins make it possible to produce confectionery with innovative textures like vegan marshmallows and firm-elastic fruit gummies and flavours...

Related suppliers

Follow us

Featured Events

View more

Products

View more

Webinars