Unconstitutional: Virginia Governor vetoes bill targeting plant-based 'milk'

By Elaine Watson contact

- Last updated on GMT

Virginia Governor vetoes bill targeting plant-based 'milk'

Related tags: plant-based milk, oatmilk, GFI, Plant Based Foods Association, almondmilk

Virginia Governor Ralph Northam has vetoed a bill that would have limited the use of the term ‘milk’ on food labels to the lacteal secretions of hooved animals.

HB 119​​​ – which would have prohibited terms such as 'oatmilk' or almondmilk' on food labels, even if used with qualifiers such as ‘dairy-free' or 'plant-based’ – defined ‘milk’ as the “lacteal secretion, practically free of colostrum, obtained by the complete milking of a healthy hooved mammal..."

In a statement​ explaining his April 11 decision, Governor Northam explained: "Eliminating the ability to label certain food products with the term 'milk' could hinder some businesses’ ability to thrive in Virginia. This bill likely conflicts with both the United States Constitution and the Constitution of Virginia and each’s protection of commercial speech."

Alena Yarmosky, a spokeswoman for Northam, told the Washington Post​:​ “While the Governor is very supportive of the dairy industry, he is concerned this bill is unconstitutional and could violate commercial freedom of speech.”

GFI: 'This is a victory for free speech, free markets, and consumer choice'

The move was welcomed by Jessica Almy, policy director at The Good Food Institute (GFI)​, which promotes plant-based meat and dairy and cell-based meat: “This is a victory for free speech, free markets, and consumer choice.”

GFI senior policy specialist Scott Weathers added: “Consumers should be the ones to pick the winners and losers in the marketplace — not special interests lobbying in state legislatures.”

The Plant Based Foods Association said the decision was "a major victory for the plant-based foods industry. By allowing plant-based milk companies to label their products accurately, Governor Northam is promoting a business-friendly environment that allows for plant-based innovation in Virginia."

Impossible Burgers retail packaging

How is coronavirus impacting plant-based meat? Impossible Foods, Lightlife, Tofurky, Meatless Farm Co, Dr. Praeger's, weigh in

While some shoppers have shared photos of empty meat cases next to fully-stocked shelves of plant-based meat on social media, the latest Nielsen data suggests that retail sales of meat alternatives increased significantly in March alongside their animal-based counterparts. However, brands that have focused on foodservice face significant near-term challenges.

Read more HERE.

Co-sponsor: ‘Last year, Virginia lost up to three dairy farms a week’​

While Plant Based Foods Association​ (PBFA) executive director Michelle Simon had warned​ that the bill would confuse consumers and “do nothing to help struggling dairy farmers,”​​ Chris Runion (R-Rockingham) – who co-sponsored HB119 in the House – insisted it was “about giving the consumer correct information and being truthful in advertising.”​​

Plant-based ‘milk’ and consumer litigation​

Consumer class actions challenging terms such as ‘almondmilk’ and ‘soymilk’ have not made much headway, with judges arguing​​​​ that the federal standard of identity for ‘milk’​​​​​​​ - which limits it to lacteal secretions from cows - does not categorically preclude a company from using names that include ​​​​​​the word ‘milk’ (e.g. 'soymilk') as long as they use qualifiers such as ‘plant-based’ or ‘dairy-free.’

In an order dismissing one such case vs brand owner Blue Diamond Growers in 2017, Judge Stephen V. Wilson also gave short shrift to the ‘nutritional equivalence’ argument made by Runion: “A reasonable consumer, indeed even an unsophisticated consumer, would not assume that two distinct products have the same nutritional content.”​​

In January 2019, the Ninth Circuit court of appeals upheld the dismissal​​​ of the above class action and argued that reasonable consumers would not assume from the packaging that almondmilk is nutritionally equivalent to dairy milk.

Meanwhile, a federal district court in Arkansas recently determined​​​ that a challenge to a state law restricting ‘meaty’ terms on plant-based products was likely to prevail on the merits of its First Amendment claim.

So_Delicious_Dairy_Free_Oatmilk_Yogurt_Alternatives

According to SPINS data collated by the GFI and the PBFA, plant-based options account for 14% of the fluid milk market; 4% of the yogurt market; 6% of the butter market; 5% of creamers; 3% of ice cream and frozen novelties; and 1% of the cheese market (52 weeks ending Dec. 29, 2019).

Related news

Related products

show more

Beyond amazing plant-based burgers start here!

Beyond amazing plant-based burgers start here!

Roquette: Improving well-being by offering the best of nature | 25-Jun-2020 | Application Note

With demand for plant-based foods up an incredible 278% since this time last year, food and beverage manufacturers are scrambling to boost their catalog...

Convenience foods + culinary standards

Convenience foods + culinary standards

Cargill | 09-Jun-2020 | Technical / White Paper

Keeping pace with modern lifestyles and current trends, today’s convenience category has the opportunity to re-invent itself and earn a consistent place...

Product Recovery (Pigging) for Food Manufacturers

Product Recovery (Pigging) for Food Manufacturers

HPS Product Recovery Solutions | 25-Nov-2019 | Technical / White Paper

Sanitary product recovery ("pigging") is in wide use by food manufacturers that pump liquids or wet products.
It gives a high ROI and...

Related suppliers

Follow us

Products

View more

Webinars