Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - North AmericaEU edition | APAC edition

Trends > Natural claims

Is it too risky to market foods containing GMOs as 'all-natural'?

3 comments13-Nov-2012
Last updated on 13-Nov-2012 at 15:44 GMT2012-11-13T15:44:47Z

Is it too risky to market foods containing GMOs as 'all-natural'?

Consumers, market researchers tell us, want foods that are ‘wholesome’, ‘authentic’, and above all ‘natural’, although few of them can articulate what this means. And they are not alone. Regulators have not had much of a stab at defining ‘natural’ either, says Justin Prochnow, an attorney in the Denver office of law firm Greenberg Traurig.

All the FDA has said is that firms can use 'natural' on labels provided it is used in a manner that is truthful and not misleading and the product does not contain added color, artificial flavors or synthetic substances, observes Prochnow, who caught up with FoodNavigator-USA at Supply Side West in Las Vegas last week.

But what about high fructose corn syrup, partially hydrogenated vegetable oils, GMOs and a whole raft of other ingredients that some consumers feel do not belong in a product labeled as ‘all-natural'?

It's down to who the judge believes

If an opportunistic plaintiff's attorney can argue persuasively that his client - and other reasonable consumers - might feel misled if a food containing GMOs or HFCS is marketed as 'natural', he has a case, adds Prochnow.

"And then it's down to who the judge believes. And this is why so many of these cases are being settled...

"Companies look at it and decide is it really worth spending two years fighting and what could be a million dollars or more on a case that we probably have a 50:50 chance of winning."

Click here to read about the class action lawsuit filed against Pepperidge Farm last week over 'natural' claims on Goldfish crackers.


3 comments (Comments are now closed)


Justin above says it all, 'if an attorney can argue persuasively'. This says the case has nothing to do with right or wrong, but who can be the more persuasive.
And as for why companies settle, why wouldn't they? They will pay out i.e. say $50,000 to get it over with. Most of these lawsuits are simply blackmail as the attorneys know the companies will settle. If the attorney or the plaintiff really was serious about thier cause, they would not settle, but see it through. It has nothing to do about GMO, natural, healthy, or how I was mislead.
It is all about the pay day.

Report abuse

Posted by Mike
15 November 2012 | 15h472012-11-15T15:47:07Z

Natural and Born Again

If GMO's are 'natural', perhaps we should consider Frankenstein as "born again"?

Report abuse

Posted by Jennifer Chistiano
13 November 2012 | 16h562012-11-13T16:56:19Z

It should be a criminal offense...

Using GMO ingredients in a product marketed as "healthy" or all-natural should be a criminal offense. "Big Food" and "Big Pharma" don't care about health, safety or long-term effects, they care about profit. I say, let's take a few of these turkeys to court and dig into those profits with gusto.

The language of money is universal. Financial pain is always remembered, and these huge conglomerate companies are due for some ACUTE pain.

Report abuse

Posted by banh
13 November 2012 | 14h312012-11-13T14:31:49Z

Vox Pop: Consumers had this to say about GMO labeling...

Vox Pop: Consumers had this to say about GMO labeling...

On the heels of President Barack Obama signing into law a federal bill requiring...

Gluten-free products evolve as more nutritious, flavorful

Gluten-free products are evolving to be more nutritious, flavorful, Firebird Artisan Mills says

The gluten free market in the US remains hot, but as the category becomes...

Fiber helps cut sugar, calories; preserve taste, satiety, clean label

Fiber rises on ability to cut sugar & calories while preserving taste, satiety and clean label

While fiber hasn’t quite reached the same superstar status as protein, consumer interest in...

LovePulses Showcase highlights pulse versatility at IFT

More than just beans: Finalists from all corners of the world share their pulse innovations at IFT

An energy bar, jam, and even gelato—these aren’t food items often associated with pulses...

TerraVia CEO talks algae at IFT: We have disruptive products

TerraVia CEO: Thrive culinary algae oil could be a sizeable consumer brand

TerraVia – formerly known as Solazyme – has been telling reporters (and investors) that...

Sloan Trends at IFT: Moves away from fortification 'very troubling'

Sloan Trends: 'The move away from fortification is very troubling'

Manufacturers have been ‘cleaning up’ food labels for years, but the pressure to oust...

Dairy Permeate cuts sodium, costs & boosts nutrition, USDEC says

Dairy Permeate cuts manufacturing costs and sodium while boosting nutrition, USDEC says

Most Americans consume more than 1.5 times the daily recommended cap for sodium –...

Meeting consumer demand for ‘simple’ isn’t simple, Mintel says

Meeting consumer demand for ‘simple’ isn’t as simple as it appears, but it is possible, Mintel says

Consumers increasingly are seeking products that they are simple, with ingredients that they can...

Edible insects beyond whole cricket powder at IFT

Will the edible insects market move beyond whole cricket powder?

Milled whole cricket powder is probably the best known bug-derived food ingredient aside from...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Hummustir navigates potentail of DIY food trend

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Hummustir navigates market potential of DIY food trend

As recently as 15 years ago, most Americans had never heard of hummus, or...

Soup-To-Nuts: The evolution of local food to do-it-yourself options

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: The evolution of local food to do-it-yourself options

Consumer demand for local food and beverages is no longer a niche market –...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast:The rise & future potential of grass fed claims

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast:The rise & future potential of grass fed claims

Grass-fed claims on products are a beacon for consumers who are health-conscious, want minimally...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: What does it take to boost seafood consumption?

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: What does it take to drive up seafood consumption in the US?

Seafood checks many of today’s on-trend boxes, including being high in lean protein and...

Soup-To-Nuts podcast: What is old is new again

Soup-To-Nuts podcast: What is old is new again

Trends may come and go, but they often don't stay gone forever -- rather...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Meeting sodium sugar & calorie reduction demands

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: How can manufacturers meet sodium, sugar & calorie reduction demands?

Finding solutions to reduce sodium, sugar and calories in finished products is essential as...

The rise of ‘ethical claims’ and their marketing potential

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: The rise of ‘ethical claims’ and their marketing potential across categories

Consumer demand for products and companies that “do good” – such as donate a...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Consumers' evolving taste for chocolate

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: How is consumer interest in health reshaping how they choose chocolate?

Consumers’ increasing demand for healthier options is reshaping the competitive landscape across categories –...

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Five trends spotted at Summer Fancy Food Show

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Five trends spotted at Summer Fancy Food Show

With thousands of startups, innovators and established brands packed into one convention center, the...

Soup-to-Nuts Podcast: What GMOs are & how they impact health & Earth

Soup-to-Nuts Podcast: What are GMOs and how do they impact the health of humans and Earth?

With the effective date for Vermont’s GMO labeling law officially here and the debate...

Key Industry Events