Plant-forward diets may reduce greenhouse gases, but to meet nutritional needs, emissions would increase

By Elizabeth Crawford contact

- Last updated on GMT

Source: Getty
Source: Getty
Just as there is not only one diet that is best for the health of all people, so too is it true for the health of the planet, according to new research from the Johns Hopkins Center for a Livable Future.

“It would be satisfying to have a silver bullet to address carbon footprints and the impact of food production,”​ which plays a significant role in climate change, but “with problems as complex and global as nutrition, climate change, freshwater depletion and economic development, that’s not possible,”​ according to Martin Bloem, director for the center and the Robert Lawrence professor of environmental health at the Bloomberg School.

“There will always be tradeoffs,”​ he added in a statement accompanying the study he co-authored that was published Sept. 16 in the journal Global Environmental Change.

The study examined how nine different plant-forward dietary patterns across 140 countries would impact individual- and country-level greenhouse gas emissions and freshwater use and found there was no one-size-fits all diet that could simultaneously address climate change, obesity and undernutrition – all of which share food production and consumption as key underlying drivers.

Plant foods were generally the least GHG-intensive overall

To assess the impact of each diet, the researchers not only considered which foods were consumed, but took into account their impact on greenhouse gas, blue and green water footprints, the health of the population, and import patterns and associated difference between the production of foods in different countries of origin.

Broadly speaking, the researchers found that the most greenhouse gas intensive food source “by far”​ was ruminant meats, including cows, sheep and goats. Cow meat weighed in on average at 6.54 kg C02e/serving. This was 316 times more intensive than pulses, 115 times more than nuts & seeds and 40 times more than soy.

“Plant foods were generally the least GHG-intensive overall, often by an order of magnitude, even after accounting for GHGs associated with deforestation for palm oils and soy,”​ the study notes.

Similarly, the impact on blue water was most harmful for pond-raised fish and farmed crustaceans, it added.

Going beyond individual foods, the researchers found that while a vegan diet had the lowest environmental impact, not everyone needs to give up all meat to have a positive impact. Rather, it found that diets with protein predominantly from low food chain animals, such as small fish, were nearly as low as a vegan diet in terms of environmental impact. Similarly, adopting a ‘two-thirds vegan diet’ generally had a lower impact than a traditional vegetarian diet that includes eggs and cheese.

Impact of whole diets

The impact of whole diets on nutrition and the environment, however, is not as cut and dry as it is with individual food groups in part because of the impact posed by importing foods that on their own may have a lower environmental impact to replace locally grown foods.

For example, “a country-specific analysis reveals, for example, that shifting to the meatless day diet reduced GHG and water footprints in 47% and 57% of study countries, respectively – with some of the greatest per capita reductions in Paraguay, Israel and Brazil – even though the average net effect was an increase in footprints,”​ the study notes.

In another example, the authors note that one pound of beef from Paraguay creates 17 times more greenhouse gases than one pound of beef from Denmark.

Another wrinkle in the findings comes when the researchers considered nutrition guidelines for countries. This variable showed that even when a low red meat or meatless day diet was adopted by all countries alongside nutrition goals to account for under and over consumption, there was still an average net increase in diet-related greenhouse gas and water footprints. Most of this impact came from populous countries where under consumption is a significant problem.

In response, the authors stressed, “interventions that aim to address both sustainability and health goals must ensure plant-forward shifts are ambitious enough to offset the potential ecological burdens associated with providing adequate nutrition.”

Reflecting on these results, Bloem noted that “environmental impact alone cannot be a guide for what people eat; countries need to consider the totality of the nutritional needs, access and cultural preference of their residence.”

He added: “The good news is this research can be a part of the solution, as it now gives policymakers a tool to develop nationally appropriate strategies, including dietary guidelines that help meet multiple goals.”

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Create plant-based products that consumers prefer

Create plant-based products that consumers prefer

Archer Daniels Midland Company | 21-Oct-2019 | Technical / White Paper

It takes more than just knowing what protein options exist to create irresistible, consumer-preferred foods. As products starring plant-based proteins...

REAL Eggs Integral Role in Baking White Paper

REAL Eggs Integral Role in Baking White Paper

American Egg Board | 06-Oct-2019 | Technical / White Paper

By enhancing ingredient statements, REAL Eggs contribute to gold standard quality. In a world where consumer expectations evolve at sometimes dizzying...

Color plus clean labels from a proven ingredient

Color plus clean labels from a proven ingredient

Briess Malt & Ingredients Co. | 06-Sep-2019 | Product Presentation

BriesSpecialty™ Malt Flours offer natural color and flavor adjustment for cookies, breads, and other grain-based foods. Ranging in color from light to...

Related suppliers

3 comments

How i was cured

Posted by Lisa Stepp,

Hello everybody,
I don't just know the reason why some people is finding it difficult to believe that there is a cure for herpes, I have been suffering from herpes since last three years with my boyfriend but today I am happy that am cure from it with the herbal medicine of Dr Aza the great healer,I was browsing the internet searching for help when I came across a testimony shared by someone on how Dr Aza cure his herpes I was so much in need of getting his treatment but after all Dr Aza brought a smile to my face with his herbal medicine. I am so much happy today that we have someone like this great healer out there, so my people out there kindly contact this great healer on his email address:  drazaherbalcenter@gmail.com.please sir keep your good work cause there are people out there who is in need of your healing medicine.once more contact him now:  drazaherbalcenter@gmail.com.   you can call him or whatsApp his number +1(315) 795 1518

Report abuse

Thank you so much Dr Tebor for saving my life I'm forever greatiful sir

Posted by Caroline,

TESTIMONY OF HOW I GOT CURED FROM HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS This is real take it serious, i am so happy that today i can give this testimony to the world and also help in saving life of people who has been condemned for death just as i was ,who will believe that a herb can cure herpes, i never believe that this will work, i have spend a lot getting drugs from the hospital to keep me healthy, it got to a time that all i was waiting for is death to come because i was broke, one day i heard about this great man called DR.TEBOR through an online friend who publicly made a testimony on how she was also cure of herpes simplex virus2 by this herbal doctor who is well known for his strong ancient herbal practice for Herpes, HIV, and Cancer cure,at first i doubted but later i decided to give him a try so i emailed him I didn't believe him that much, I just wanted to give him a try, he replied my mail and Needed some Information about me, then I sent them to him, he prepared a herbal medicine (CURE) and sent it through Online Courier Service for delivery, he gave my details to the Courier Office. they told me that 3-5 days I will receive the package and after receiving it, i took the the herbal medication send to me by him at the end 7 days, he told me to go to the hospital for a check up, and i went, surprisingly after the test the doctor confirm me Herpes simplex virus negative, i thought it was a joke, i went to other hospital and was also negative, thank you for saving my life, I promise I will always testify of your good works. if you are herpes simplex virus patient, contact him and I am sure you will get cured, contact him via: email at Teborherbalcenter@gmail.com and mobile phone:+2349059544255 OR you can what-apps him +2349059544255 THESE ARE THE THINGS DR.TEBOR HERBAL HOME CURE . HERPES . HIV/AIDS . CANCER . Syphilis, You can also visit him on his website https://teborherbalcanter.wordpress.com

Report abuse

herbal cure for HIV

Posted by cooker lola,

Thanks to dr.LOSA for his good work I never believe that HIV has cure, I
was HIV positive over 3 year now before I came across a comment about
how
dr.LOSA cure HIV and herpes disease but when I saw it i have it in mind
that he can’t cure HIV I just decided to give it a try I contact him
that
night luckily to me he replied me, but I don’t believe him I thought it
was
a scam but I still hold on to see the work of Dr LOSA if he is saying
the
truth he ask for some details about me i gave him all he needed and I
waited to see his reply to my problem after all, he told me to go for
check
up and I went for HIV test I cant believe I was negative,am so happy and
grateful to God for using Dr LOSA to cure me, that is the reason why i
decided to write this wonderful testimony of our i was cured, i
recommend
Dr LOSA to you all around the world,contact him on his Email
dr.losaherbalhome@gmail.com or call/WHATSApp +2349056464736 you can also reach him through
thanks
dr.ONUWA for helping me at this young age if you need help contact,
He can also cure so many sickness
{1}HIV And AIDS
{2}Diabetes
{3}Epilepsy
{4} Blood Cancer
{5} HPV
{7} ALS
{8} Hepatitis
{9}Love Spell

Report abuse

Follow us

Featured Events

View more

Products

View more

Webinars