Grass-fed is greener, says Maple Hill Creamery: ‘We need to have a more nuanced conversation about dairy and sustainability’

By Elaine Watson

- Last updated on GMT

New York state-based Maple Hill makes yogurt, kefir, drinking yogurt and cheese from 100% grass-fed organic milk
New York state-based Maple Hill makes yogurt, kefir, drinking yogurt and cheese from 100% grass-fed organic milk

Related tags Cattle Milk

Dairy can get a bad rap in debates on animal welfare and sustainability, but it’s time the conversation became more nuanced, says 100% grass-fed, organic and “unapologetically full-fat” dairy brand Maple Hill Creamery, which is now available in 6,000 stores from Walmart to Sprouts and growing rapidly on the back of surging interest in all things grass-fed.

Founding farmer and CEO Tim Joseph told FoodNavigator-USA: “Consumers write my paycheck so they will decide what to buy, but I do get frustrated when I hear people make assumptions about what’s more environmentally-friendly ​[eg. dairy vs ‘plant-based’] as not all dairy is the same, and there are so many benefits to grazing.

"Even among natural and organic consumers, the level of ignorance around agriculture is astounding. Everyone knows just enough to be dangerous.

"Big monocrops of soy or other plants ​[that are used in some dairy alternatives] still need inputs (fertilizers, pesticides etc) whereas our ‘inputs’ are grazing - manure from the grazing cows, and we’re regenerating the soil, supporting wildlife biodiversity, sequestering carbon and limiting pollution of waterways."

100% grass-fed dairy cows have a longer, healthier life than their conventionally-fed counterparts

As for differences between different dairy farming methods, Maple Hill's 'closed loop' model - whereby cows eat grass from pasture and baleage and spend most of their time on pasture -“bypasses the considerable resources used produce the corn, soybeans, or grains​” fed to conventionally-raised dairy cows (grass-fed cows produce manure, which feeds the soil that grows the grass they eat), he added.

Its 100% grass-fed dairy cows also have a longer, healthier life than their conventionally-fed counterparts, he claimed: “Our cows​ [Maple Hill procures milk from 100 farms in the New York State area] enjoy daily access to the outdoors all year round, and are generally only in the barn for milking time.

"They socialize with their herd mates, and are less stressed and happier than cows in CAFOs ​[concentrated animal feeding operations] or even large organic dairy farms. In the winter they eat hay ​[dried grass] and baleage ​[fermented, high-moisture grass], so they are 100% grass fed.”  

Maple Hill Creamery Cows

Maple Hill Creamery's 100% grass-fed cows typically live "at least twice as long as conventional dairy cows, and have fewer health issues,"​ claims the company.

Without a third-party certification, consumers cannot be certain of how much grass the cows actually are consuming

As the term ‘grass-fed’ is not legally defined by the FDA, however, and USDA organic certification only guarantees that dairy cows have access to pasture/forage for 30% of the year, no two grass-fed claims are the same, which is misleading consumers and creating an uneven playing field, he claimed.

Without a third-party certification, consumers cannot be certain of how much grass the cows actually are consuming, which is why we’ve worked with PCO ​[organic certifier Pennsylvania Certified Organic​] to develop standards for 100% grass-fed​ and we’re working with other brands in this space such as Organic Valley via the American Grassfed Association​ to get some standards​ in place. We could have gone to the FDA first but if you go down that route things move so slowly that we didn't want to wait. It's an important claim and it needs to be backed up."

maple hill creamery drinkable yogurt

Consumers think grass-fed means exclusively grass fed

But why does it matter if one 'grass fed' brand uses milk from cows eating grass for 120 days a year, and another uses milk from cows fed grass 365 days a year?

For a start, because the milk will vary across the year, said Joseph (grass-fed milk has higher levels of beta-carotene and CLA (conjugated linoleic acid), a higher ratio of omega-3 to omega-6 fatty acids, and a different, earthier, flavor.

"The cow is making milk every day, so the production system should involve grass every day.

Tim Joseph Maple Hill Creamery
Tim Joseph: “When we started, hardly anything was being marketed as grass-fed, but around two and a half years ago it really started to bubble up in the trade, and since then it has really exploded.”

“In beef you see this 'grass-fed, grain-finished' claim, which isa bit disingenuous because it just puts a new name on the current system and doesn’t change the system or improve animal welfare, it bugs the heck out of me."

Consumers, meanwhile, think ‘grass-fed’ means exclusively​ grass-fed, he said. “We recently did some focus groups and something like 80% of people thought this. There was a strong feeling that cows should not be eating grains and corn, which really surprised me, as I don't think you would have heard that a couple of years ago.

"They also had this very strong sense that we need to go back to doing things the way they used to be done, the way they should be done, and that grass fed means healthier, happier cows, which that means healthier milk, even if they don’t have a detailed understanding of what that means ​[in terms of the milk’s composition].”

A strong regional supply, a national brand footprint

But how easy is it to procure grass-fed milk for his products (which he originally made in-house but now manufactures via a network of co-manufacturers)?

maple hill creamery yogurt
Maple Hill's milk is pasteurized, but not homogenized [a mechanical process that breaks the fat globules into smaller droplets so that they stay suspended in the milk rather than separating out] so a layer of cream rises to the top of the cup.

New farmers Joseph is working with typically fall into three categories, he said: First, new generation dairy farmers; second, conventional farmers that want to transition to grass-fed in part because of the volatility of regular milk pricing; and third, organic farmers that have seen their margins suffer owing to the high price of securing non-GMO feed for their cows.  

“We want to build a strong regional supply with a national brand footprint.”

Retailers are looking for more grass-fed dairy products 

So are retailers enthused by the grass fed dairy opportunity?

Yes, said Joseph, who sold a minority stake in Maple Hill to Sunrise Strategic Partners​ in November in order to raise cash and tap into the expertise of the management team there, which is led by former Boulder Brands executive Steve Hughes.

While not all retail buyers are as engaged as Joseph is by the debate over 'grass-fed' claims, that may change as consumers become more educated about what grass-fed means, and actively seek out 100% grass-fed products, he predicted.  

"Grass-fed is definitely opening doors for us, so we want to grow our footprint and also go deeper [add more SKUs] with existing customers. We've been generating 60-100% growth year on year, which is pretty exciting.

"We have a strong base in natural and organic retailers but we've also been growing a lot in conventional because Maple Hill attracts higher spending consumers and retailers want those higher value baskets."

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Replacement Isn't the Future. Variety Is.

Replacement Isn't the Future. Variety Is.

Content provided by ADM | 22-Mar-2024 | White Paper

Successfully navigating the intersection of food and technology can help your business meet evolving consumer demands.

Some home truths about real prebiotic dietary fibre

Some home truths about real prebiotic dietary fibre

Content provided by BENEO | 22-Mar-2024 | Product Presentation

Confused about prebiotics? You’re not the only one! Food developers wanting to work with prebiotic dietary fibre are faced with an abundance of products...

Consumer Attitudes on Ultra-Processed Foods Revealed

Consumer Attitudes on Ultra-Processed Foods Revealed

Content provided by Ayana Bio | 12-Jan-2024 | White Paper

Ayana Bio conducted the Ultra-Processed Food (UPF) Pulse survey, offering insight into consumers’ willingness to consume UPFs, as well as the variables...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more