‘Henry Ford did more for horses than animal rights activists ever did… technology has enabled us to align our ethics with our behaviors.’ Paul Shapiro talks cell-based meat

By Elaine Watson contact

- Last updated on GMT

Paul Shapiro: These are not ‘alternative’ products
Paul Shapiro: These are not ‘alternative’ products

Related tags: cell-based meat, cell-cultured meat

No one likes factory farming. But most people still eat meat regardless. Put another way, persuading consumers to change their behavior hasn’t really moved the needle, says cell-cultured meat enthusiast and author Paul Shapiro. Offering a technological solution (growing meat without killing animals) means they won’t have to. They can have their cake (well, meat), and eat it too.

By mass-producing cars, Shapiro told delegates at the Industrializing Cell Based Meat Conference​ in San Francisco last week, “Henry Ford did more for horses than animal rights activists ever did​.”

Technology makes it easy for consumers to do the right thing [anyone still lighting lamps with whale blubber?], said Shapiro, author of the best seller, ‘Clean Meat: How Growing Meat Without Animals Will Revolutionize Dinner and the World​​. “Technology has enabled us to align our ethics with our behaviors.”

In the not too distant future, said Shapiro (who noted that meat consumption is still on the rise in the US despite surveys showing consumers claim to be cutting down), we may look back at factory farming as not only a cruel, but hopelessly inefficient, way to produce protein from a bygone era.

What’s in a name? It’s imperative we resist any efforts to push for an alternative designation for these products’

While some stakeholders worry whether consumers will accept cell-cultured meat, and debate whether marketers should emphasize its animal welfare or sustainability credentials, he added, most food purchase decisions come down to taste, price, and convenience, and if consumers try a Memphis Meats burger, like it, and it’s safe and affordable, why wouldn’t​ they buy it again?  

That said, finding the right terminology for cell-cultured meat will be important, although it’s hard to find something that’s going to satisfy all stakeholders, he acknowledged.

Whether the descriptor is ‘cell-based,’ ‘clean,’ ‘slaughter-free,’ cell-cultured,’ ‘cell-farmed,’ or something else, however, the products are still ‘meat,’ he said.

These are not ‘alternative’ products and it’s imperative we resist any efforts - whether it’s from the incumbent industry or anyone else - to push for an alternative designation for these products, because it’s just meat… just in the same way that the FTC has recognized​ that cultured diamonds ​[diamonds produced in a lab by heating carbon to extreme temperatures and applying extreme pressure] are still diamonds​.”*

Branding will likely also play a key role in introducing the public to cell-cultured meat, he said, noting that Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods have reached new consumers (meat eaters/flexitarians) by building brands that focus on how delicious the products are​,​ rather than lecturing people about saving the planet or improving their health, even if these are important purchase drivers for some consumers​.

“No one thought electric cars were cool until Tesla came along.”

Hybrid products

One avenue that is worthy of further debate is hybrid products combining plant-based and cell-cultured meat, argued Shapiro, who is also a co-founder of Better Meat Co​, a start-up targeting institutional food sellers with plant-based proteins that blend into ground meat products at inclusion rates of up to 30%.

The Better Meat Co
Sacramento-based start-up The Better Meat Co is targeting institutional food sellers with plant-based proteins that “blend seamlessly into ground meat products” at inclusion rates of up to 30%, to deliver healthier, tastier, and more sustainable sausages, burgers, and meatballs.

While on the face of it, a plant-meat combo might seem like the worst of both worlds – it’s not all meat, which may put off some meat lovers, but it’s not all plants, which automatically excludes vegans and vegetarians – the success of the blended burger project​​ (which promotes burgers with 75% meat and 25% mushrooms)​ suggests consumers are open to a hybrid approach.

Indeed, foodservice companies are increasingly open to blended meat products for health reasons (they have less saturated fat and fewer calories) or environmental reasons (they have a lower carbon footprint, and many companies have targets to meet on this front), said Shapiro.

There won’t be one solution​ [to reducing our dependence on traditional meat production],” he added, noting that plant-based products have been around for years but have failed to make a significant dent in the market (yet), while meat consumption continues to rise despite growing awareness of animal welfare and sustainability issues.

If the default option in a corporate cafeteria is a pork sausage that’s half pork and half plant-based protein, with less saturated fat, fewer calories, and the same level of protein, and it tastes just as good, consumers wouldn’t have to change their behavior, he said.

“The whole premise of our company is to help make the default option the better option. Just as we want to see plant-based meat in the meat aisle, we also want to see it in the meat.”

* In summer 2018, the FTC removed the word ‘natural’ from its definition of diamonds: ‘a natural mineral consisting essentially of pure carbon crystalized in the isometric system’ ​meaning the term could equally apply to man-made and mined diamonds.

Further reading:

From edible scaffolding to bio-printing: What would an industrial-scale cell-based meat plant look like?​ 

The ‘world is watching’ the cell-based meat industry, says Memphis Meats VP: ‘Subpar early products can stigmatize an entire category for decades to come’

'Cell-based meat’ not the most consumer-friendly term, reveals GFI consumer research

Cultured meat cos agree to replace term ‘clean meat’ with ‘cell-based meat’ and form trade association

GUEST ARTICLE: Food fight over the M-word​ 

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Create plant-based products that consumers prefer

Create plant-based products that consumers prefer

Archer Daniels Midland Company | 21-Oct-2019 | Technical / White Paper

It takes more than just knowing what protein options exist to create irresistible, consumer-preferred foods. As products starring plant-based proteins...

REAL Eggs Integral Role in Baking White Paper

REAL Eggs Integral Role in Baking White Paper

American Egg Board | 06-Oct-2019 | Technical / White Paper

By enhancing ingredient statements, REAL Eggs contribute to gold standard quality. In a world where consumer expectations evolve at sometimes dizzying...

Color plus clean labels from a proven ingredient

Color plus clean labels from a proven ingredient

Briess Malt & Ingredients Co. | 06-Sep-2019 | Product Presentation

BriesSpecialty™ Malt Flours offer natural color and flavor adjustment for cookies, breads, and other grain-based foods. Ranging in color from light to...

Plant-based meat alternatives market motivators

Plant-based meat alternatives market motivators

DuPont Nutrition & Biosciences | 01-Apr-2019 | Technical / White Paper

Market analysis shows steady growth in the plant-based meat alternatives segment over the past few years as consumers eat more plant-based foods. The reason...

Related suppliers

Follow us

Featured Events

View more

Products

View more

Webinars