FDA urged to enforce identity standards to prevent dairy product ‘imitation’

By Mark Astley

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags: Milk

Senator Dan Coats (pictured) along with Richard Lugar and Kristen Gillibrand have urged the FDA to enforce dairy identity standards.
Senator Dan Coats (pictured) along with Richard Lugar and Kristen Gillibrand have urged the FDA to enforce dairy identity standards.
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has been urged by three members of the US Senate to increase its enforcement of regulations that prevent the “imitation” of standardised dairy products.

Senators Dan Coats, Richard Lugar and Kristen Gillibrand called on the FDA to enforce its Standards of Identity regulations in a letter addressed to FDA commissioner Margaret Hamburg.

Standards of identity, which are outlined in the Code of Federation Regulations, are legal standards which define a food’s minimum quality specification including permitted ingredients and processing requirements.

According to the letter, it has become increasingly common to find products on the market that use the names of standardised dairy products such as milk, despite not meeting specific requirements.

The US National Milk Producers Federation (NMPF) has given its backing to the senator-led campaign, pinpointed soy milk as the biggest violator of the FDA dairy standards.

The senators expressed concerns that “these misleading labels will become even more prevalent and further erode the meaning of these dairy terms.”

“Haphazard enforcement”

“We are writing to express our concerns regarding the haphazard enforcement efforts of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to prevent the misbranding of certain food items that are imitations of standardised dairy products,”​ said the letter.

“Federal standards of identity are established to promote honesty and fair dealing in the interest of consumers. Dairy product standards contain provisions regarding both permitted and prohibited ingredients, as well as proper manufacturing procedures to protect product identity.”

In the US, standards of identity have been established for milk, cream, sour cream, yogurt, ice cream and some types of cheeses.

However, products such as soy milk have continued to be manufactured in violation of the FDA regulations.

“It is clear from scattered enforcement actions that the FDA understands these terms should not be used in such a manner for imitation dairy products. However, given the increasing prevalence of mislabeled imitation dairy products, FDA enforcement has not been sufficient,” ​added the letter.

While the senators accept that consumers may choose these “imitation” ​dairy products for a variety of reason, it is “inappropriate for manufacturers of these products to violate the law and continue to mislead consumers by capitalising on dairy terminology for standardised foods.”

“Imitation dairy products should be allowed on the market only when accurately labeled.”

Soy milk – worst offender

“The letter is very consistent with the letters we have previously sent to the Congress and the FDA,” ​said NMPF spokesperson Chris Galen referring to the organisations 12 year campaign against standardised dairy product imitation.

“Our initial concern was that we were seeing a number of products in supermarkets using the term soy milk, which is not permitted in the US.”

Almond, rice and hemp products labelled as ‘milk’ have since become prevalent, he added.

“It started with soy, and now it encompasses a much wider spectrum of products.”

“If it’s not going to be enforced then what’s the point?”​ added Galen.

Related topics: Regulation, Dairy-based ingredients

Related news

Related products

show more

A Novel Prebiotic for Food & Beverage Innovation

A Novel Prebiotic for Food & Beverage Innovation

AIDP, Inc | 26-Feb-2020 | Technical / White Paper

Until now, incorporating prebiotics into food and beverages has been a challenge, with high efficacious doses and unwanted side effects. PreticX® is the...

Accelerate your supply chain as pressures intensify

Accelerate your supply chain as pressures intensify

William Reed | 02-Sep-2019 | Technical / White Paper

Food, Drink and Non-Food manufacturers are under pressure. Range reviews, massive retail mergers, the backlash against plastic packaging and the ongoing...

Everything about in-container sterilization

Everything about in-container sterilization

John Bean Technologies (JBT) | 01-Nov-2018 | Application Note

JBT has a long history and an extensive track record in thermal processing of packaged food. JBT retorts and sterilizers are renowned for their outstanding...

Related suppliers


Show more

Humans still drink cow's milk? WTF

Posted by Marten Felgnar,

I'm still in awe when I hear that people continue to drink cow's milk despite the overwhelming evidence that it "Doesn't do a body good"
Milk is a disgusting, pus filled liquid most suited to calfs...yuk!! I'll stick to Soy or Almond MILK,thank you very much....

Report abuse


Posted by Chris,

This is one of the most ridiculous things I've seen lately. The dairy industry doesn't own the word milk. There was such a thing as coconut milk long before soy milk became popular. Do these Senators not have anything better to do?

Report abuse

Milk Redefined

Posted by Jon Owen,

I think what the senator and his associates should consider instead is the idea of milk et al. We're living in a day when scientific research has shown that cow's milk isn't nearly as good for us as we thought it was. And the idea of milk holds more of a cultural suggestion as a white opaque drink that provides choice nutrients than does a requirement from cows.

I personally think in light of the higher health benefits, and often price difference, maybe milk should be rethought as to what it's required to be instead.

Although with a milk lobby this strong in our country, it's unlikely that'd ever happen.

Report abuse

Follow us


View more