Coca-Cola Life goes nationwide, but Coke silent on report claiming it has ‘an undeniable hit on its hands’

By Elaine Watson

- Last updated on GMT

Coca-Cola Life is sweetened with a combination of cane sugar and stevia
Coca-Cola Life is sweetened with a combination of cane sugar and stevia

Related tags Coca-cola life Coca-cola

Stevia-and-sugar-sweetened Coca-Cola Life is rolling out nationwide this month following trials in The Fresh Market stores in four US states. But Coca-Cola has declined to comment on a new report claiming that it has already proved to be an “undeniable hit”.

In a statement​ ​on its website Wednesday, Coca-Cola said the mid-calorie, naturally-sweetened cola - which has 60 calories per 8-oz glass bottle vs 93 calories for 8oz of regular Coke - is rolling out to supermarkets, c-stores and drug stores across the country.

However, it chose not to comment on a report from consultancy Haynes & Co ​claiming that sales were "likely better than expected" ​in North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia and Florida; that customers "love it"; ​and that it has "an undeniable hit"​ on its hands.

The Haynes research - which follows an October 1 report from Sanford Bernstein claiming that Coca-Cola Life had got off to a ‘lackluster’ start (click HERE​) - included an online survey of several hundred consumers who recalled seeing Coca-Cola Life in stores, and 72 who had purchased it; in-store field research in Atlanta; and a telephone survey of Fresh Market store managers in 22 stores in all four trial states.

It was conducted between September 26 and October 3.

It found that:

  • 80% of purchasers said they would buy Coca-Cola Life again.
  • Being like full-sugar Coca-Cola in taste was important to 60% of purchasers, and nearly the same percentage felt it was close to or exactly the same in taste.
  • For 45% of respondents, Coca-Cola Life had replaced 75% or more of their normal soda purchases.
  • Half of respondents said they were buying more soda as a result of having Coca-Cola Life as an option.
  • 50% of store managers said repeat purchasers were already a core part of the emerging Coca-Cola Life consumer base, while 50% of stores contacted had sold out at least once.
Coke Life displays source Haynes & Co

The product looks and feels upscale

According to Haynes & Co president and founder Elizabeth Haynes: “The green label helps this product stand out … From end-cap displays in the deli aisle to prime positioning at front doors with healthy and organic snacks, the product looks and feels upscale en masse… 

Coca-Cola Life’s new rival Pepsi True - which has 60 calories per 7.5oz can, compared with 100 calories for the equivalent amount of regular Pepsi - is available exclusively on Amazon in 24-packs of 7.5-ounce cans, a move PepsiCo says will help it assess demand ahead of a wider launch

“Overall, with incredibly positive store sentiment - Haynes & Company analysis putting the average store score at 4.5 stars (of out of 5) – and equally high marks from consumers – 70% of purchasers rate the taste 4 or 5 stars – we believe all signs point to Coke having an undeniable hit on its hands.”

All signs point to Coke having an undeniable hit on its hands

But why does her research suggest a picture so much rosier than that recently painted by Sanford Bernstein?

Haynes told FoodNavigator-USA she couldn't comment on the earlier data, but said that she was confident she had an accurate picture:

“We believe that a new product launch succeeds in the marketplace by laddering consumer behavior: first, getting them to pick it up and try it for which newness and visual appeal must be there; second, delighting them when they actually taste the product; and third, being relevant enough that the consumer purchases again and again.  This product, based on our triumvirate approach, is giving off signs of success to us."

While some store managers complained about the roll-out (not getting product on time, not getting replacement product), the only negative feedback was that "some customers and managers felt that it tasted like "flat Coke Zero", but even these managers were positive on the product overall", ​she said.

Jonas Feliciano headshot
Jonas Feliciano

Jonas Feliciano: I’m not convinced that this represents a long-term solution for carbonate decline in the US

Jonas Feliciano, senior beverages analyst at Euromonitor International, told FoodNavigator-USA it would be fascinating to see if sales data supported some of this encouraging consumer sentiment.

He added: "There is something definitely unique about the green label alone – enough of a change that draws consumer eyes and encourages them to try the product and also signifying that this product is indeed 'different' from the Coke or Diet Coke that they are used to. Part of the problem with Pepsi Next was they were still trying to sell consumers on the replication of full calorie products rather than embracing this as something familiar, yet new.

"That said, I’m not convinced that this represents a long-term solution for carbonate decline in the US. The problem of 'close but not quite' taste still exists and is compounded by the fact that this beverage is a mid-calorie product – something that has never worked in the past.

"Coke Life and Pepsi True may seem to be a better alternative to full flavored and zero calorie colas, but to turn the tide, these products need to be a better choice than flavored/functional bottled waters, liquid water enhancers, new flavors of energy drinks, RTD teas or any other category that has seen growth at the expense of carbonates."

Initial success may be tied to green labels rather than a wider acceptance of stevia  

As for what Coke Life and Pepsi True will do for stevia, it's still too early to say, he added.

"I believe initial success may be tied to the innovative green labeling rather than a wider acceptance of stevia as a solution. With the nationwide launch, stevia will be under a giant microscope as consumers, media and the scientific community all weigh in on, not only the naturally occurring plant, but the process by which it is created.

"Is stevia ready for this spotlight? And are Coca-Cola and Pepsi the companies best suited to handle its image?"

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Sustainably sourced. Naturally versatile.

Sustainably sourced. Naturally versatile.

Content provided by Covation Bio™ PDO | 15-Apr-2024 | Insight Guide

Zemea® USP-FCC propanediol is a 100% plant-based alternative to petroleum-based glycols. Used as a flavor carrier, processing aid and humectant, this ingredient...

Some home truths about real prebiotic dietary fibre

Some home truths about real prebiotic dietary fibre

Content provided by BENEO | 22-Mar-2024 | Product Presentation

Confused about prebiotics? You’re not the only one! Food developers wanting to work with prebiotic dietary fibre are faced with an abundance of products...

Related suppliers


Show more


Posted by P Nocke,

I do not like Stevia. I buy the full cane sugar Coke made in Mexico.

Report abuse


Posted by Julie,

Wow it put the wrong date. Is 3/7/16. Coke not available in cans. Tastes Great though bottles expensive.

Report abuse


Posted by Julie,

Love Coke Life though bottles are expensive. Also no place to recycle glass. Can't find the cans anymore dince first came out. Want the 6 pack cans. Where are they available at? Stores no longer carry them around here in Evansvile

Report abuse

Follow us


View more